Yes, and of everything you can control at home, freezing direction matters most. It only works under one condition, though: the ice has to grow from one side, and slowly enough that dissolved air can move ahead of it instead of getting trapped. Change the direction but keep the freeze fast, and you'll still get cloudy ice. Even when both conditions hold, direction doesn't purify the water. It moves the cloudiness to one place you can cut away.
To see why, you only need one mechanism. Everything else in this article follows from it.
One mechanism explains all of it: ice pushes out what it can't hold
Liquid water holds dissolved air, and ice holds much less. As water freezes, the extra air gets pushed out of the growing crystal. Purdue University's materials engineering explainer on ice cubes describes this as the source of cloudy ice. Physicists studying bubble formation describe the same thing in more detail: the growing ice rejects dissolved gas, the gas builds up just ahead of the freezing front, and once that thin layer is supersaturated, bubbles form and grow there. When the front moves past them, they're sealed into the ice (arXiv study of bubble growth near a solidification front).
Dissolved solids behave the same way. Food engineers rely on this in freeze concentration: pure ice crystals form, and the dissolved material stays behind in the liquid that hasn't frozen yet (IFT, "Getting a Fix on Freeze Concentration").
So freezing acts like a sweep. Air and dissolved minerals get pushed ahead of the ice, and they collect wherever the freeze finishes. Where the last water freezes is where the cloudiness ends up. You can't stop the sweep. What you can control is where it finishes.
Why freezing in one direction works

Suppose the ice can only grow from one surface, say from the top down, while the sides and bottom stay warmer. Then the freezing front is a single surface moving through the water in one direction. Rejected air is pushed ahead of it the whole way, toward the far end.
Purdue calls this directional solidification. Freezing from one end to the other pushes the extra air across the slab and releases it as the last water freezes. The air never gets trapped in the middle, so the ice it passed through stays transparent. Purdue notes that variations of the technique are used for ice sculptures and restaurant clear ice.
The key point is that the air still goes somewhere. The freeze carries it to the end, where it either escapes or gets trapped in the final cloudy section. Direction gives you a clear region and a cloudy region with a clean boundary between them. It doesn't turn the whole block clear.
Why a fast freeze defeats it

Direction alone isn't enough, because the sweep only works if the gas can keep ahead of the ice.
The bubble research says the size and shape of trapped bubbles depend on two rates: how fast the freezing front moves, and how fast dissolved gas can diffuse away from it. If the front moves slowly, gas has time to spread into the liquid ahead and isn't forced into bubbles at the boundary. If the front moves fast, gas piles up at the boundary faster than it can leave. It reaches supersaturation, forms bubbles, and the ice closes over them. In a fast freeze, a front moving in a single direction still leaves a trail of bubbles behind it.
Freeze-concentration engineers deal with the same problem from the other side. The IFT article describes the process as mass-transfer controlled. As the leftover liquid becomes more concentrated, it gets thicker, and material moves away from the ice surface more slowly. Removing heat quickly makes more ice sooner, but that works against clean separation. Speed and clean separation pull in opposite directions.
In practice, that means a directional setup in a very cold freezer can still give you bubbly ice. If you change the direction and the improvement is smaller than you hoped, the freezing rate is the next thing to check.
Why an ordinary tray can't do it
A freezer tray is close to the worst case for this mechanism. Each cell is small, thin-walled, and surrounded by cold air on almost every side. Purdue describes what happens next: freezing starts at the outside and works inward. Every wall pushes rejected air toward the center, and the center is the last place to freeze. The air has nowhere left to go, so it gets trapped there as the familiar cloudy core.
You can't fix this by adjusting the tray. The cloud in the middle of a tray cube isn't a defect. It's where a freeze from every side has to end. To move the cloudiness out of the middle, you need to stop most of the walls from freezing first. That's why insulated methods work. Insulating the sides and bottom of a container slows heat loss there, so the uninsulated surface freezes first and the front moves in one direction, away from it.
What a home setup can realistically deliver
A one-direction freeze in a home freezer gets you a block with a clear section and a cloudy section where the freeze ended. You end up with:
- A clear section on the side where freezing started, with the best clarity nearest that surface.
- A cloudy section where the freeze finished, holding the trapped air and concentrated minerals.
- Extra work: getting the block out, separating or trimming off the cloudy end, and cutting the clear part into pieces you can use.
Be honest about the costs. Slower freezing is what makes the ice clear, so the process takes longer than filling a tray. Part of every batch gets thrown away. Your results will also vary with your freezer, your container, and how much insulation you use, which is why we're not giving a universal container size, temperature, or timing here. Treat your first batch as a measurement, not a finished recipe.
Filtering or boiling the water changes something else: what's dissolved in it. It doesn't change where the freeze finishes. Whatever is left in the water still ends up at the last section to freeze.
Read your ice: where the cloudiness sits tells you what to change

Before you change anything, look at a cube or block you've already made and note where the cloudiness is.
- A cloudy core in the center, clear edges. The ice froze from every side and finished in the middle. This is a direction problem. Insulate so only one surface freezes.
- A cloudy layer at one end, clear elsewhere. Directional freezing is working. Trim off that end. If the cloudy part is larger than you want, slow the freeze.
- Fine bubbles or streaks spread through the "clear" section. The direction is right, but the front moved too fast for the gas to escape. Slow the freezing rate.
- White, chalky film or gritty residue, especially on equipment. That's minerals, not air. Direction won't fix it (see below).
- Fresh ice is clear but stored cubes turn white on the surface. That's frost or meltwater refreezing on the outside during storage, not a freezing-direction problem.
Where direction stops helping: minerals and scale
Directional freezing moves dissolved minerals. It doesn't remove them. With hard water, which Nebraska Extension describes as water high in dissolved calcium and magnesium picked up from soil and rock, more of those solids get concentrated into the last section to freeze. A directional freeze puts them in the end you cut off. A tray puts them in the center of every cube.
Inside an ice machine, those same minerals can build up as scale, and Nebraska Extension notes that scale can impair water-using appliances. That's a maintenance problem, not a freezing-direction problem. If you see buildup in a machine, our guide to hard water, freeze-ups, and mineral scale in ice makers covers how to handle it. Hard water isn't a health hazard, but it will keep showing up until you deal with it directly.
When you need repeatable clarity: the rate-versus-clarity tradeoff, built in
A home directional freeze is worth doing to understand the mechanism. It's harder to repeat the same result every time, because you have to keep the freezing rate, the insulation, and the trimming consistent from batch to batch.
If you'd rather have consistent clear ice than run a weekend project, our Euhomy Countertop Clear Ice Maker makes 2-inch square cubes in two modes: Rapid Mode produces two clear cubes in about 27 minutes, and Crystal Mode produces two crystal-clear cubes in about 45 minutes. The larger, dense cube also melts more slowly than smaller traditional cubes.
To decide whether it fits, ask two questions. First, do you need the clarity of the 45-minute cycle, or is the 27-minute clear cube good enough for how you use ice? Second, will a 2-inch cube fit the glasses you actually use? If cloudy ice from a different countertop machine is what brought you here, our explainer on cloudy vs. clear ice from countertop ice makers picks up from here.
The one test to run this week
Fill a small, clear-sided container with water. Insulate the sides and bottom, leave the top open to the freezer, and freeze it. Before it's completely solid, take it out and look through the side.
If the top is clear and the cloudiness is gathered toward the bottom, directional freezing is working in your freezer, and your remaining choices are how slowly to freeze and how much to trim. If the cloud is still in the middle, cold is getting in through the sides, so add insulation. If bubbles run all the way through, the freeze is too fast. That one container tells you which of the three variables to change next.